I have a half-dozen small complaints about Kindle, and mostly I'm a happy user. But Google does very little to improve on Kindle, which is disappointing.
For instance, I haven't seen what Google does when you buy 100 books, which is overwhelming and hard to understand on a Kindle device.
But I have two other complaints that don't seem to be addressed in what appears to be a Kindle clone:
- Typography. Books have a personality, and a lot is due to the uniqueness of their layout and typographic choices. Much is lost in the eBook of today.
Real-life books use unique fonts, and they have a variety of typographic settings. Instead, by making every book conform to the same exact point size, to the same leading, to the same font (Georgia, but, look, I can switch to Times!), is boring and makes switching between books feel less engaging.
The world would be better if eBooks used Typekit, or even if they had random defaults to adjust their typography, to give a little more personality. Within a certain kind of variation (small color, spacing changes, etc.), readability wouldn't be impacted, but switching between the 5 books you're currently reading would be very much improved. Recognition at a glance is important, whether that's a book cover or a page. Today's eBooks badly need a typographic personality.
- Search. Another major limitation with a Kindle, especially the hardware version, is that "flipping through" is very slow. Google does a decent job "flipping" online with the arrow keys, but Google's search solution on the Web is no better than Acrobat's...it's off to the side, and dissociated from the paging interface. It's a 1998 interface.
Why not make accessing reference books much better than Kindle? For instance, why isn't search somewhere near the paging interface, and why aren't the results shown in the same spot instead of in a sidebar? Similarly, moving the slider bar doesn't flip through pages (or better, zoom out!)...instead it just does nothing at all until you mouse-up.
Openness is only a theoretical benefit. User experience is a real one. I don't see a real competitor to Amazon (on any front) right now.